Assumes there was ever a definitive version.
If you follow Yang Zhengduo a full list and explanation of the moves can be found in Yang Style Taijiquan*1 written in1988 By Yang Zhengduo. Prior to that, the definitive work for Yang The Essence And Applications Of Taijiquan from Yang Chengfu*2 (allegedly ghost written by Ch'eng Man-Ching Page xi) in 1934 also contains a full comparable list.
The wave does appear to be missing with Yang Chengfu, and the moves are counted differently. Also 5 instead of 3 combinations of repeats are widely practised contrary to the book. (though not by Yang Jun who does 3). This is again covered by the general understanding Yang Chengfu demonstrated it differently to different levels of students and at different periods in his life. In Yang Zhengduo's book Raise Hands & Step Forward there is an obvious example of the move ending sooner and then being classed as White Crane than in Yang Juns current demonstrated version but the full move is done by both. Yang Jun publishes instruction through the Yang Family Association. Yang Jun seems to have changed the Interpretation from Yang Zhengduo.
There aren't any visual examples of Yang Luchan (1799-1872) preforming. You have to jump to Yang Chengfu (1883-1936). None of him either other than photo's. However he did have a renowned student called Fu Zhong Wen (1903-1994) who became a Disciple (recognised expert) and so highly respected that Yang's first Disciple Chen Weiming (Not Ch'eng Man-Ching. He did change it.) wrote a letter to Fu Zhong Wen after Cheng Fu's death. The letter recognising the excellence of Fu Zhong Wens’ accomplishment and the accuracy with which he reflected their master’s art.
Now Fu Zhong Wen you can watch up to the end of second section. Not a Yang Family member but one who carried on the tradition.
Fu Zhong Wen
For the pedantic, he does do five Repulse Monkey, Cloud Hands and Parting The Wild Horses' Mane as opposed to three which seems almost certainly accurate of his day and his style shown here was at the later years of his life. His interpretations are based on his own experiences (the meanings of moves) as opposed to blind copying. Fu is presented as somebody who had spent his life defending the Yang Family style and would agree to fight anybody who was stupid enough to ask to test his conclusions.
The Family Form is passed on from Yang generation to Yang generation. Each Head of the Yang family offers their own interpretations but the moves are set. If you have studied seriously you may notice changes in steps and arm movements, but you will really have to have studied. Many are obviously age related, but many have deeper reasons.
If you can spot and wonder at the subtities of the differences, not only from one Yang generation to the next, but also the great Masters, then you are on to something.
You can find out more about him here Fu Zhongwen
See also, Why So Many Yang Syles?
Back